GitHUB with Private Repository from Organization

For some reason I can't find simple directions on using IntelliJ with my Organization. I am currently the owner of this organization.

Here's where I am:

     I have a project on my local machine.

     I want to publish this into GitHUB into a private repo of my organization

     I have created this private repo on the GitHUB site.

     I have installed Git locally and put my GitHub credentials in

When I go to VCS->Share->Import into Version Control->Share on GitHUB I have the private repo checkbox grayed out.

All I want to do is push this code into a private repository for my organization. What am I doing wrong?

thanks!

R.